GP Headlines
Analysis

Ferrari's Driver Problem Boils Over After Hamilton and Leclerc Collide in Las Vegas

Charles Leclerc's collision with Lewis Hamilton halved the points Ferrari was running for in Las Vegas, leaving Fred Vasseur promising action and second place in the constructors' standings less secure than before.

By GP Headlines Editorial · · 6 min read
Ferrari's Driver Problem Boils Over After Hamilton and Leclerc Collide in Las Vegas
Illustration

Charles Leclerc was given a 10-second penalty for colliding with his Ferrari team-mate Lewis Hamilton during the Las Vegas Grand Prix, the latest in a series of on-track clashes between the pair. Hamilton recovered to finish seventh and Leclerc came home 10th, so Ferrari left Nevada with seven points on a night when Max Verstappen won and McLaren took second and third. Team principal Fred Vasseur has since vowed to “take action”. After Las Vegas, that promise needs to be more than a warning.

Seven points lost on lap 37

The arithmetic is unflattering. Hamilton and Leclerc were running sixth and seventh on lap 37 when they made contact. Had they simply held those positions, Ferrari would have scored 14 points. Instead it collected seven: six for Hamilton’s seventh place and a single point for Leclerc in 10th.

The stewards, who later set out their reasoning for the sanction, held Leclerc responsible. He did not argue. Speaking to GPfans, he described himself as “embarrassed” and admitted he had put Ferrari’s race “in the bin”. That candour is to his credit, though it also makes the clash harder to dismiss as a racing incident.

Hamilton’s response was more measured in tone and more pointed in substance. In comments reported by Motorsport.com, he suggested that Leclerc’s “frame of mind” had cost the team a lot of points. He later told PlanetF1 that Ferrari “deserve better”. The distinction matters. An error of judgement in a single corner can be forgiven and forgotten. A question about a team-mate’s mentality is harder to answer, and it moves the dispute from one lap of one race to the relationship as a whole. Hamilton chose his words carefully, and he will have known exactly where they would land.

A team-mate battle with real stakes

Part of the reason this keeps happening is that both drivers have something specific to race for. Andrea Kimi Antonelli has already settled the drivers’ title: his 98-point lead over Verstappen cannot be overturned in the two rounds that remain. Below him, the fight for the remaining places is unusually tight.

PositionDriverTeamPoints
2Max VerstappenRed Bull304
3Lewis HamiltonFerrari267
4George RussellMercedes264
5Lando NorrisMcLaren264
6Charles LeclercFerrari250

Hamilton is three points clear of both Russell and Norris in third, and 37 points behind Verstappen with 50 still available from two grands prix. Leclerc is 17 points adrift of Hamilton, and the pair have one win apiece. For each Ferrari driver, the other is the most immediate benchmark. Neither has much incentive to concede ground in a straight fight, because the person each of them most needs to beat is wearing the same overalls.

That is the context for Jacques Villeneuve’s recent criticism. The 1997 world champion told RacingNews365 that Leclerc had “lost” the “leadership” of Ferrari once Hamilton arrived. That overstates it. Leclerc remains the faster qualifier on many weekends, and leadership at Maranello has never been a title handed out by a single result. But the standings now put Hamilton ahead in his second season with the team. A driver who feels his status slipping is more likely to force a move in the final third of a race, and the Las Vegas incident fits that pattern uncomfortably well.

The constructors’ arithmetic Ferrari cannot ignore

Mercedes is out of reach in the constructors’ championship. Its 149-point lead over Ferrari is larger than the 86 points a team can score from two grands prix, and it has won 12 races to Ferrari’s two. Ferrari’s realistic goal for 2026 is second place, which carries prize money and a measure of credibility after a season in which Mercedes has dominated.

Las Vegas made that goal less certain. Red Bull scored 25 points and McLaren 33, against Ferrari’s seven.

  • Ferrari: 517 points
  • Red Bull: 440 points (77 behind)
  • McLaren: 431 points (86 behind)

Before the weekend, Red Bull was 95 behind and McLaren 112 behind. Ferrari remains a strong favourite to finish second, and McLaren would need two perfect weekends combined with a Ferrari collapse even to draw level. Red Bull’s route is only slightly less improbable. Still, a team that gives away seven points in one evening through a collision between its own cars is not managing its advantage. It is inviting the very scenario it should be closing down.

Interlagos 2019, Barcelona 2016 and the meaning of “consequences”

Ferrari has been here before. At the 2019 Brazilian Grand Prix, Leclerc and Sebastian Vettel touched while fighting over fourth place late in the race, and both cars were out on the spot. Mattia Binotto called both drivers in to explain themselves. The friction that followed shaped the rest of their time together, which ended when Vettel left at the end of 2020. Leclerc was the younger, rising driver in that partnership. Seven years on, the roles are not neatly reversed, but he is now the long-serving incumbent facing a decorated arrival.

Mercedes offers the more instructive precedent. After Hamilton and Nico Rosberg took each other out on the opening lap in Spain in 2016, and touched again on the final lap in Austria weeks later, Toto Wolff put team orders openly on the table. Mercedes did not ultimately impose a hierarchy. It did tighten its rules of engagement and made clear that further contact would carry penalties within the team. The drivers kept racing, but with a clearer understanding of where the limits lay. Hamilton lived through that regime, and his remark that Ferrari “deserve better” reads like the view of someone who has seen a team fix this problem before.

There is a sharper example from more recent memory. When Esteban Ocon hit Pierre Gasly on the opening lap at Monaco in 2024, Alpine spoke of “consequences”, and Ocon’s departure from the team was announced shortly afterwards. Vasseur used the same word this week, according to GPfans. Nobody should read that as a hint about anyone’s future at Maranello. It does show how far the language has escalated.

What Vasseur should do before Lusail

Vasseur’s realistic options range from a private dressing-down to formal team orders. The worst choice would be to pick a side. Ferrari’s interest over the next two rounds lies in securing second in the constructors’ standings, and that is not the same as Hamilton’s interest in holding third in the drivers’ standings, or Leclerc’s interest in closing the 17-point gap to him. The team should not trade one driver’s ambitions against the other’s. It should take the decision out of the cockpit at the specific moment when these incidents happen.

The fix is straightforward and has precedent. Once the final pit stops are complete, positions between the two Ferraris should be frozen unless the pit wall releases them, and the rule should apply equally to both cars. Before the last stops, the drivers can race each other. After them, the priority is to bring both cars home. Neither driver loses face, because neither is being told he is second best. Both lose the option of turning a late-race fight for sixth into a costly incident for the team.

The Qatar Grand Prix on 29 November is the test. Lusail rewards commitment through its long, fast corners and offers few comfortable places to pass, which is exactly the kind of track where a frustrated driver tries something ambitious. If the two Ferraris are running nose to tail in the final stint and the pit wall leaves them to settle it themselves, Vasseur’s vow will have been nothing more than words. If he freezes the order and both drivers accept it, Ferrari can see out the season in second place and use the winter to reset the partnership rather than let the rivalry deepen.

Share

Get the F1 round-up in your inbox

Our daily round-up and every race-weekend recap — free, no spam, unsubscribe anytime.